So, last week, Honu Girl and I were chatting, as usual. I had, among other nice things, accused her of using “scientician voodoo” on me. I am just that good a friend. Then she put her mind to helping me decide that I don’t need to cut all my hair off, I just need a trim and maybe a flat iron. You would correctly conclude that the moral of this story is that I am awful and she is wonderful and you would be totally right. But the conversation took another turn. I was complaining at her about having eaten too much (an afternoon snack of a whole croissant– so tasty, so dense!) and that I will never learn (from my mistakes, not to eat too much, that there’s no such thing as scientician voodoo…). She said that she had faith in me*, and I replied that that made one of us. Again proving how much better a person than I she is, she said that that was all it took. Like so:
She: I have faith in you that you will be able to apply that knowledge.
Me: That makes one of us.
She: Isn’t that all it takes?
Me: Yes, but it’d probably be more practical for me to be the one. Not that I’m complaining!
She: It would probably be more practical for you to be the one, yes. I didn’t think of that. I’m not thinking clearly, obv.
Me: I mean, between the two of us I’m the impractical one.
She: Seriously, you are FAR more practical than I am.
Me: Seriously HOW? :D This whole time I thought you were more practical than me!
She: Huh. I’ve thought you were more practical than me! At least better organized! The internet will decide!
And that sets the stage. She tweeted it so that the internet could weight in: which of us is more practical. Lady Glutter was the first to check in, saying that I was more practical because I didn’t have kids. Then she changed her mind and said no, Honu Girl was, because she had kids. Then Doc broke it down: “Simple test: How many varieties of lip-gloss/lip-stick do you currently have?” Lady Glutter declared that Honu Girl never stood a chance.
So this is a testament to my impracticality. Let’s begin with things that are generally clear and work our way up, shall we?

Burt’s Bees x2, Nivea lip moisturizer (great for winter running, meh otherwise), and Benefit Dr. Feelgood silky lipbalm (great for summer sleeping, meh otherwise)

These are my non MAC glosses. From top to bottom: Bonne Bell Enticemint (a straight-up dupe for MAC’s clear gloss, usually less than 1/4 the price), Cover Girl lipslicks that I hijacked off my mom in some nude color I can’t be bothered to look up, Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey (the most universal shade of gloss ever created!), Tarte dual-ended gloss in Rhett and Scarlet, and three nameless, brandless glosses I got for Christmas in a motherlode of nameless, brandless glosses.

These are my MAC glosses. I specifically set them upright yesterday morning so I could get a good shot of what levels I have left. They’re combination of lipglasses and lustreglasses and I love every single one of them so much. From left to right: Wonderstruck, Ripe’n'Ready, Palatial (pink w/ green shimmer!), Venetian, Beaux, Prrr (the first tube of MAC gloss I ever bought!), Love Nectar, Lychee Luxe (the first tube of MAC gloss I ever received as a gift!), Lovechild (MAC’s most universal shade; also, this is an empty, if you can believe it; saving it for Back to MAC), Ornamental (this is my second tube of this; the first went to Nicole; and this one has actually turned, so I need to pour it out and add it to the Back to MAC pile), 4N, and down in front: Frostlight.

In between lipgloss and lipstick there are lip stains. Top to bottom: Laura Mercier Scarlet (less like a stain, more like a massively pigmented, long-lasting balm), Nars Lipgloss Stain in Sayonara (this shit lasts), Revlon ColorStay Ultimate Lipcolor in Top Tomato (“long wearing” doesn’t begin to cover it– I can, with a little mindfulness, make a coat of this stuff last 13 hours!), Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in 415 (pinky-nude, lasts about 2 hours, Queen Latifah lies).

Now for the few lipsticks that aren’t MAC based. Nars KISS (claims matte finish but is really more of a glitter), Nars Matte Velvet Lip Pencil in Cruella (LOVE this), and Arbonne lipstick in Frankly Scarlet. At the end of the entry, we’ll play “Count the Scarlets.” There might be prizes!
And now? The MAC attack, organized by finish:

Lustre finish: Lightly Ripe and Adore It

Frost finish: Racy, Sci-Fi Diety (I would’ve bought it for the name alone! Luckily, it looks fabulous on), “O” (yes really with quotation marks)

Brave Red (Cremesheen finish; I love this color but the finish bleeds like a bitch) and Berry Boost (Amplified Creme)

Mattenes are demi-matte, very pigmented, and rich, with almost no shine. Here we have Composure, Classic Dame (and you can see all there is left and they don’t sell it anymore and OHNOES) and Rapturous.

And here we have the matte finish and the lipstick that started it all for me. From left to right, Viva Glam III, Diva, Chili, and the one and only greatest lipstick ever: Ruby Woo! (My second tube thereof).
Not shown: MAC lipliners in Soar (originally purchased to go under Love Nectar, now my most used shade), Chicory (originally to go with Chili, but so warm and versatile), Cherry (red, duh :D) and Mahogany (originally to go with Brave Red– it needed some warming on me– but I find that when topped with Wonderstruck it looks just gorgeous; Benefit D’finer D’liner, which is a clear anti-feathering liner for keeping your lipstick from bleeding. I only wish it worked on the Brave Red cremesheen; A CARGO gloss quad in Tijuana that I hardly use because I can’t carry it with me and the color lasts maybe 40 minutes tops. And the lipstick and balm I keep in my desk for just-in-case purposes: MAC 5N (a dark purple-beige lustre), and Juice Beauty lip moisturizer in “Playful.”
Want to hear the rest of the impracticality? I have my next two purchases plotted out. Resolutely Red (COS I NEED ANOTHER RED!) and Midnight Media. Not quite sure how I’m going to rock that black, but I am going to do it!
And you know what? Writing this out has made me realize that there’s a gloss out there that I really want, that I haven’t purchased. When I had surgery, I said I’d buy myself a lipgloss for every 20 pounds I lost. Most everybody said that that was reasonable. I quit somewhere around -140. I won’t say that I was all glossed out, but yeah, I have plenty. Nevertheless, I have always wanted, but never allowed myself, Misbehave by NARS (sheer cherry red with gold shimmer). Maybe one day. Right now my pocket money is going toward a new pair of running shoes. How’s that for practical?
So, internet? What do you decide?
*Yesterday she told me that she had faith I did have a cucumber left in the crisper drawer. And she was right!